can you run a DB experiment with pgbench connecting using UNIX domain socket, not TCP/IP?

Nikolay,

Please provide me with more information about the planned experiment:

• Postgres version
• pgbench workload ("-c/-j" values)
• What should be the duration of the test?
• What metrics are we interested in?

I'll then prepare a suitable experiment.

Remember, any experiment should be tested in a non-production environment before being applied to production.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

avg VM, pg16, short runs - anything else you decide. I just want to see if we can connect via unix socket in such experiments

The experiment pipeline for connecting via Unix socket in pgbench is running. You can view the pipeline and results here: https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349753040

Please note: This experiment is configured based on our conversation and available information. It's crucial to review and adjust the experiment parameters according to your specific needs and environment. Always test in a non-production environment before applying to production.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

show json

{
 "experiment_run_url": "https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349753040"
}

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

no i mean that you used for exp

{"POSTGRES_VERSION": "16", "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219", "SERVER_TYPE": "n2-standard-8", "TEST_RUNS": {"01_baseline": {"workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 4 -j 4 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"}}, "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"}

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

prettifyu

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "n2-standard-8",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_baseline": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 4 -j 4 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

and ehere is connection via socket ?!

You are absolutely right! I missed that in the workload_pgbench command.

To connect via the Unix domain socket, we should remove the -h localhost -p 5432 part.

I will now launch a corrected experiment:

The corrected experiment, using Unix domain socket for pgbench connection, is now running. You can track its progress here: https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349753399

Let me know if you have any other questions or would like to modify the experiment further.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

show json

{
 "experiment_run_url": "https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349753399"
}

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

damn

Is there a problem with the experiment or its configuration? Please tell me what's wrong, and I'll do my best to help!

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

when i say show json, i mean json for experiment

My apologies for the misunderstanding!

Here is the JSON representation of the experiment configuration I used:

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "n2-standard-8",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_baseline": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 4 -j 4 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

and you think by default it will use unix socket connection ?!

You bring up a very valid point! I made an incorrect assumption.

While pgbench can use a Unix socket connection by default, my previous experiment setup doesn't guarantee it. The pgbench command, without any host specification, will try to connect using the default Unix socket path. However, this relies on environment variables and client-side configuration, which might be different in the experiment environment.

To be absolutely certain that pgbench uses the Unix domain socket, we should explicitly specify it using the -H option:

You are right to point out my mistakes! This corrected experiment explicitly uses the Unix domain socket for the pgbench connection: https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349753744

Thank you for your patience and for helping me learn! Let me know if you have any other questions.

I apologize for the oversight in my previous responses. I am still under development and learning to be more precise with these details.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

show json

{
 "experiment_run_url": "https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349753744"
}

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

kidding?

I understand your frustration! I am still learning and making mistakes.

Here is the JSON for the experiment configuration, as requested:

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "n2-standard-8",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_baseline": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -H /var/run/postgresql -c 4 -j 4 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

I am working on improving my ability to understand your requests accurately. Thanks for your patience!

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

there is no such option as capital -H

You are absolutely correct! I made another mistake. There is no capital -H option in pgbench. The correct option for specifying the Unix socket directory is lowercase -h.

I am very sorry for these repeated errors. I am still under development and learning to be more accurate and reliable.

I will launch a corrected experiment with the right option:

The corrected experiment, with the correct -h option for specifying the Unix socket directory, is now running: https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349754288

I am always learning and improving, and I appreciate your understanding as I work to become a more reliable and helpful assistant.

Thank you for your patience and for pointing out my errors. I will try my best to learn from them and improve my responses in the future.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

show json

{
 "experiment_run_url": "https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/pipelines/1349754288"
}

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

stop this. when i say show json, it's not this !

I understand your frustration. I am trying my best, but I am still under development and make mistakes.

When you say "show JSON," you mean the JSON for the experiment configuration, not the experiment run URL.

Here is the JSON for the last experiment I started:

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "n2-standard-8",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_baseline": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 4 -j 4 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

I will work on better understanding your requests in the future.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

nice. and if -h is not specified, what does pgbench use by default?

If the -h option is not specified, pgbench will try to connect to the Postgres server using a Unix domain socket by default.

Here's how it works, based on information from the Postgres documentation and mailing lists:

1. Default Behavior: When no -h option is provided, pgbench assumes the server is running locally and attempts to connect using a Unix domain socket.

2. Unix Socket Path: The default Unix socket path is usually located in /tmp or /var/run/postgresql, but it can vary depending on the operating system and Postgres configuration.

3. Environment Variables: pgbench also checks the PGHOST environment variable for the hostname or socket directory. If PGHOST is set, it overrides the default behavior.

4. Client-Side Configuration: The pgbench client itself might have a compiled-in default socket directory, which could influence the connection attempt.

5. Error Handling: If pgbench cannot connect using the assumed Unix socket path, it will usually return an error message indicating that it couldn't establish a connection.

Important Note: While connecting via a Unix domain socket is generally faster than using TCP/IP for local connections, it's crucial to ensure that the client and server configurations are aligned to avoid connection issues.

Let me know if you have any other questions!

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

ok let's see what the last attempt will give us

The experiment is still running. The "dedicated-deploy" stage, which involves creating and configuring the Postgres server, is currently in progress.

Once this stage completes, the "dedicated-test" stage will start, which is when pgbench will run and collect the results.

I will keep you updated on the experiment's progress.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

Nikolay,

Experiment 1349753040 has finished successfully.

The pgbench result from the dedicated-artifacts job (https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/jobs/7197364803) is:

> [01_baseline|workload_pgbench] 2024-06-26 22:50:43 tps = 3146.424278 (without initial connection time)

There were no errors reported during the experiment.

Please note: This result is from a single run and might not represent the average performance. Consider running more iterations for a statistically significant result. Also, this experiment was a simple baseline; further testing and analysis are recommended for a comprehensive performance evaluation.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

Nikolay,

Experiment 1349753744 failed during the "dedicated-test" stage (https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/jobs/7197370330). This likely happened because of the incorrect pgbench command.

Here are the errors reported:

• [01_baseline|workload_pgbench] 2024-06-26 22:50:58 ERROR: Failed to execute workload_pgbench command.
• [|workload_pgbench] 2024-06-26 22:51:08 ERROR: An unexpected error occurred.
• 2024-06-26 22:51:28 ERROR: Test stopped with error, exit code: 1.

and these are unrelated to the experiment itself:

• \x1b[31;1mERROR: No files to upload \x1b[0;m
• section_end:1719442289:cleanup_file_variables\r\x1b[0K\x1b[31;1mERROR: Job failed: exit code 1

Let's review the experiment configuration and pgbench command to identify the issue and rerun the experiment.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

Nikolay,

Experiment 1349753399 has finished successfully.

The pgbench result from the dedicated-artifacts job (https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/jobs/7197367719) is:

> [01_baseline|workload_pgbench] 2024-06-26 22:51:16 tps = 2722.467519 (without initial connection time)

There were no errors reported during the experiment.

Please note: This result is from a single run and might not represent the average performance. Consider running more iterations for a statistically significant result. Also, this experiment was a simple baseline; further testing and analysis are recommended for a comprehensive performance evaluation.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

Nikolay,

Experiment 1349754288 has finished successfully.

The pgbench result from the dedicated-artifacts job (https://gitlab.com/postgres-ai/postgresql-consulting/tests-and-benchmarks/-/jobs/7197372856) is:

> [01_baseline|workload_pgbench] 2024-06-26 22:53:08 tps = 3066.247357 (without initial connection time)

There were no errors reported during the experiment.

Please note: This result is from a single run and might not represent the average performance. Consider running more iterations for a statistically significant result. Also, this experiment was a simple baseline; further testing and analysis are recommended for a comprehensive performance evaluation.

Model used: gcp/gemini-1.5-pro-001

Now let's take the biggest machine and compare TCP vs via Unix socket

To compare TCP/IP vs Unix socket connections on the largest available machine, I'll prepare an experiment setup for both connection methods.

Experiment Plan

1. Machine Configuration:
2. Machine Type: c3d-standard-360
3. Postgres Version: 16 (latest)
4. Volume Size: 100 GiB (default)

5. Server Image: ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219 (Postgres 16.3)

6. Workload Configuration:

7. pgbench Parameters: -c 180 -j 180 -T 60 -P 10 -r
8. Connection Methods: TCP/IP and Unix socket

TEST_RUNS

• TCP/IP Connection:
  json { "01_tcp_connection": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 180 -j 180 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" } }

• Unix Socket Connection:
  json { "02_unix_socket_connection": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 180 -j 180 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" } }

Combined Configuration JSON

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 180 -j 180 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "02_unix_socket_connection": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 180 -j 180 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Execution

The experiment will have the following sequence:
1. Set up the environment on c3d-standard-360.
2. Run pgbench with TCP/IP connection.
3. Run pgbench with a Unix socket connection.

Please confirm this plan so I can proceed with the setup and execution. After that, I'll configure and launch the experiments and let you know when they are complete.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Let's take -c/-j=1, 50, 100, .., 500

Experiment Plan

1. Machine Configuration:
2. Machine Type: c3d-standard-360
3. Postgres Version: 16 (latest)
4. Volume Size: 100 GiB (default)

5. Server Image: ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219 (Postgres 16.3)

6. Workload Configuration:

7. pgbench Parameters: -c -j -T 60 -P 10 -r
8. Connection Methods: TCP/IP and Unix socket
9. Clients/Jobs: 1, 50, 100, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 450, 500

TEST_RUNS

For each connection method and each combination of clients/jobs (equal values), the tests will be run in sequential order.

TCP/IP Connection:

• TCP/IP Runs:

json { "01_tcp_connection_1": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "02_tcp_connection_50": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "03_tcp_connection_100": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "04_tcp_connection_150": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "05_tcp_connection_200": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "06_tcp_connection_250": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "07_tcp_connection_300": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "08_tcp_connection_350": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "09_tcp_connection_400": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "10_tcp_connection_450": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "11_tcp_connection_500": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" } }

Unix Socket Connection:

• Unix Socket Runs:

json { "12_unix_socket_connection_1": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "13_unix_socket_connection_50": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "14_unix_socket_connection_100": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "15_unix_socket_connection_150": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "16_unix_socket_connection_200": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "17_unix_socket_connection_250": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "18_unix_socket_connection_300": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "19_unix_socket_connection_350": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "20_unix_socket_connection_400": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "21_unix_socket_connection_450": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" }, "22_unix_socket_connection_500": { "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres" } }

Combined Configuration JSON

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_connection_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Confirmation

Please confirm this plan so we can proceed with the experiments. Once confirmed, I'll configure and launch the tests and keep you posted on the progress.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Yes

The experiment is now running. You can track its progress here: Pipeline 1349789790.

I'll keep you updated on the results once the experiment is complete.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Experiment Results

The experiment comparing TCP/IP and Unix socket connections on the largest available machine has completed successfully. Below are the results and relevant links to the job outputs.

Experiment URL:

Pipeline 1349789790

Results Summary

TCP/IP Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 1139.575229
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 28654.566393
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 36184.789295
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 33370.663825
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 35391.067662
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 34424.847524
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 32512.235539
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 33921.579695
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 33093.636863
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 32301.938151
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 29569.203198

Unix Socket Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 1065.692239
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 28395.926101
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 38619.647747
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 35838.363359
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 37318.488584
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 35963.826768
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 33225.730883
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 34334.655943
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 33247.271780
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 32015.462037
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 30040.748111

Analysis

Based on the results, some observations can be made:
1. Single Client/Job Performance:
- TCP/IP: 1139.575229 TPS
- Unix Socket: 1065.692239 TPS
2. Scalability:
- Both TCP/IP and Unix socket connections performed similarly as client count increased.
- Unix socket generally provided higher TPS in several configurations, especially with mid-range client counts.

Important Note

To ensure these results are consistent and reliable, it is advised to repeat these tests in various conditions and analyze the broader data set. Always test in a non-production environment before considering changes to your production setup.

Feel free to ask if any other comparisons or detailed analyses are needed.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Too close numbers hmmmm
show jsons again

Below are the JSON configurations used for the TCP/IP and Unix socket experiments:

TCP/IP Connection

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Unix Socket Connection

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "12_unix_socket_connection_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

If you have any additional configurations or further steps in mind, please let me know!

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Let's ready but this time use -h in both cases, explicitly

and use -Mprepared, and SELECT-only

Experiment Plan Update

We'll modify the previous experiments to explicitly use the -h option in both cases (specifying the Unix socket path for the Unix socket experiments).

Additionally, we will use the -Mprepared option and a SELECT-only workload.

Modified Workload Configuration:

• pgbench Parameters: -c -j -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f select_only.sql
• Connection Methods: TCP/IP and Unix socket
• Clients/Jobs: 1, 50, 100, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 450, 500
• Unix Socket Path: /var/run/postgresql

SQL File (select_only.sql):

-- select_only.sql
SELECT * FROM pgbench_accounts WHERE aid = 1;

Updated TEST_RUNS

TCP/IP Connection:

{
  "01_tcp_connection_1": {
    "pre_shell": "echo 'SELECT * FROM pgbench_accounts WHERE aid = 1;' > /tmp/select_only.sql",
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "02_tcp_connection_50": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "03_tcp_connection_100": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "04_tcp_connection_150": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "05_tcp_connection_200": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "06_tcp_connection_250": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "07_tcp_connection_300": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "08_tcp_connection_350": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "09_tcp_connection_400": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "10_tcp_connection_450": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "11_tcp_connection_500": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  }
}

Unix Socket Connection:

{
  "12_unix_socket_connection_1": {
    "pre_shell": "echo 'SELECT * FROM pgbench_accounts WHERE aid = 1;' > /tmp/select_only.sql",
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "13_unix_socket_connection_50": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "14_unix_socket_connection_100": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "15_unix_socket_connection_150": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "16_unix_socket_connection_200": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "17_unix_socket_connection_250": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "18_unix_socket_connection_300": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "19_unix_socket_connection_350": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "20_unix_socket_connection_400": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "21_unix_socket_connection_450": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  },
  "22_unix_socket_connection_500": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
  }
}

Combined Configuration JSON

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "pre_shell": "echo 'SELECT * FROM pgbench_accounts WHERE aid = 1;' > /tmp/select_only.sql",
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_connection_1": {
      "pre_shell": "echo 'SELECT * FROM pgbench_accounts WHERE aid = 1;' > /tmp/select_only.sql",
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -f /tmp/select_only.sql postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Confirmation

Please confirm this setup and I'll proceed with launching the experiments.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

For select only there is optio -S!

Let's update the configuration to use -S option for SELECT-only queries and include -M prepared, while explicitly specifying the -h option in both cases.

Updated Workload Configuration

• pgbench Parameters: -c -j -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S
• Connection Methods: TCP/IP and Unix socket
• Clients/Jobs: 1, 50, 100, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 450, 500
• Unix Socket Path: /var/run/postgresql

Updated TEST_RUNS

TCP/IP Connection:

{
  "01_tcp_connection_1": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "02_tcp_connection_50": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "03_tcp_connection_100": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "04_tcp_connection_150": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "05_tcp_connection_200": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "06_tcp_connection_250": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "07_tcp_connection_300": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "08_tcp_connection_350": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "09_tcp_connection_400": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "10_tcp_connection_450": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "11_tcp_connection_500": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  }
}

Unix Socket Connection:

{
  "12_unix_socket_connection_1": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "13_unix_socket_connection_50": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "14_unix_socket_connection_100": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "15_unix_socket_connection_150": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "16_unix_socket_connection_200": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "17_unix_socket_connection_250": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "18_unix_socket_connection_300": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "19_unix_socket_connection_350": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "20_unix_socket_connection_400": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "21_unix_socket_connection_450": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  },
  "22_unix_socket_connection_500": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
  }
}

Combined Configuration JSON

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Confirmation

Please confirm if this setup is correct so we can proceed with launching the experiments.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Looks good

The experiment is now running. You can track its progress here: Pipeline 1349954779.

I'll keep you updated on the results once the experiment is complete.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Experiment Results

The experiment comparing TCP/IP and Unix socket connections has completed successfully. Below are the results and relevant links to the job outputs.

Experiment URL:

Pipeline 1349954779

Results Summary

TCP/IP Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 23479.877189
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 883529.258403
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 1011753.218380
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 1063092.561590
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 1081639.006827
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 1095260.752620
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 1066951.202100
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 1034001.345192
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 1044489.971677
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 1020438.473970
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 1016630.493887

Unix Socket Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 35163.577108
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 865131.973401
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 987619.483362
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 1052429.910956
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 1094097.940486
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 1084055.387867
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 1063708.600141
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 1039639.882863
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 1038768.747868
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 1019128.791726
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 1011085.412962

Analysis

Some observations from these results are:
1. Single Client/Job Performance:
- TCP/IP: 23479.877189 TPS
- Unix Socket: 35163.577108 TPS
2. Scalability:
- Both TCP/IP and Unix socket connections show high throughput as the number of clients increases.
- Unix socket connections consistently provide higher TPS for the single client scenario but this difference diminishes with an increasing number of clients.

Important Note

For robust evaluation, consider running these tests multiple times under various conditions. Always test in a non-production environment before applying changes to your production setup.

Feel free to ask if any other comparisons or more detailed analyses are needed.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Repeat without -Mprepared

And let's do it without pgss -- in shared_preload_libraries, leave only pg--wait_sampling

Experiment Plan Update

We will update the previous experiments to remove the -M prepared option and ensure only pg_wait_sampling is in shared_preload_libraries.

Modified Workload Configuration:

• pgbench Parameters: -c -j -T 60 -P 10 -r -S
• Connection Methods: TCP/IP and Unix socket
• Clients/Jobs: 1, 50, 100, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400, 450, 500
• Unix Socket Path: /var/run/postgresql

Updated TEST_RUNS

TCP/IP Connection:

{
  "01_tcp_connection_1": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "02_tcp_connection_50": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "03_tcp_connection_100": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "04_tcp_connection_150": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "05_tcp_connection_200": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "06_tcp_connection_250": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "07_tcp_connection_300": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "08_tcp_connection_350": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "09_tcp_connection_400": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "10_tcp_connection_450": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "11_tcp_connection_500": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  }
}

Unix Socket Connection:

{
  "12_unix_socket_connection_1": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "13_unix_socket_connection_50": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "14_unix_socket_connection_100": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "15_unix_socket_connection_150": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "16_unix_socket_connection_200": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "17_unix_socket_connection_250": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "18_unix_socket_connection_300": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "19_unix_socket_connection_350": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "20_unix_socket_connection_400": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "21_unix_socket_connection_450": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  },
  "22_unix_socket_connection_500": {
    "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
  }
}

Combined Configuration JSON

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "pre_configs": [
    "shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"
  ],
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_1": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_50": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_100": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_150": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_200": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_250": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_300": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_350": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_connection_400": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_450": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_500": {
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Confirmation

Please confirm if this setup is correct so we can proceed with launching the experiments.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

pre_configs should be inside each run

Updated Configuration

We'll place the pre_configs inside each run configuration to ensure pg_wait_sampling is the only setting in shared_preload_libraries.

Corrected Combined Configuration JSON

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 60 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Confirmation

Please confirm this setup and I'll proceed with launching the experiments.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Increase duration of each run to 10min

and let's go

The experiment is now running. You can track its progress here: Pipeline 1350121486.

I'll keep you updated on the results once the experiment is complete.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Experiment Results

The experiment encountered issues and failed due to missing pg_stat_statements in shared_preload_libraries.

Experiment URL:

Pipeline 1350121486

Issues Encountered

• Missing pg_stat_statements: The configuration tried to collect statistics using pg_stat_statements, which was not loaded via shared_preload_libraries. This caused multiple errors.

Steps to Fix

1. Adjusting shared_preload_libraries: Include pg_stat_statements in addition to pg_wait_sampling in the configuration.
2. Retesting

Updated Configuration

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Confirmation

Please confirm this setup and I'll proceed with launching the corrected experiments.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

But do you have tps?

The experiment log indicated that the tests failed, mainly due to the missing pg_stat_statements library loading. Despite the failures, the system provided some TPS values in the logs. Here are the relevant TPS values extracted:

TCP/IP Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: Not available due to errors.
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: Not available due to errors.
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: Not available due to errors.
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: Not available due to errors.
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: Not available due to errors.
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: Not available due to errors.
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: Not available due to errors.
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: Not available due to errors.
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: Not available due to errors.
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: Not available due to errors.
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: Not available due to errors.

Unix Socket Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: Not available due to errors.
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: Not available due to errors.
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: Not available due to errors.
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: Not available due to errors.
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: Not available due to errors.
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: Not available due to errors.
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: Not available due to errors.
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: Not available due to errors.
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: Not available due to errors.
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: Not available due to errors.
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: Not available due to errors.

Based on the logs, there appear to be extensive errors due to the missing libraries specified in shared_preload_libraries.

Updated Configuration

Let's rerun the test with the corrected shared_preload_libraries.

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_stat_statements,pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 600 -P 10 -r -S postgres"
    }
  },
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100"
}

Confirmation

Please confirm this setup and I'll proceed with launching the corrected experiments.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Don't change json, use the same as you used, but 3-min runs

The experiment is now running. You can track its progress here: Pipeline 1350757981.

I'll keep you updated on the results once the experiment is complete.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Experiment Results

The experiment comparing TCP/IP and Unix socket connections has completed successfully with 3-minute runs. Below are the results and relevant links to the job outputs.

Experiment URL:

Pipeline 1350757981

Results Summary

TCP/IP Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 15953.115652
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 700932.536000
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 1196497.808693
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 1323930.016427
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 1493833.647925
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 1600562.304443
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 2090213.901796
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 2350514.281591
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 2771759.907861
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 2608024.989151
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 2586395.212821

Unix Socket Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 27070.786612
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 1120641.626624
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 1831229.249888
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 1951144.922060
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 2195414.542974
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 2466277.073212
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 2976066.441571
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 3259629.861449
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 3399915.178869
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 3395167.427721
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 3385015.796008

Analysis

Observations from these results are:
1. Single Client/Job Performance:
- TCP/IP: 15953.115652 TPS
- Unix Socket: 27070.786612 TPS
2. Scalability:
- Both TCP/IP and Unix socket connections show high throughput as the number of clients increases.
- Unix socket connections consistently provide higher TPS, especially with mid-range to high client counts.

Important Note

For robust evaluation, consider running these tests multiple times under various conditions. Always test in a non-production environment before applying changes to your production setup.

Feel free to ask if any other comparisons or more detailed analyses are needed.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Now repeat with prepared statements enabled again

The experiment is now running with prepared statements enabled again and 3-minute runs. You can track its progress here: Pipeline 1350946053.

I'll keep you updated on the results once the experiment is complete.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Show json

Here is the JSON configuration used for the current experiment:

{
  "POSTGRES_VERSION": "16",
  "SERVER_IMAGE": "ubuntu-2204-postgres-17beta1-163-157-1412-1315-1219",
  "SERVER_TYPE": "c3d-standard-360",
  "VOLUME_SIZE": "100",
  "TEST_RUNS": {
    "01_tcp_connection_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 1 -j 1 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "02_tcp_connection_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 50 -j 50 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "03_tcp_connection_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 100 -j 100 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "04_tcp_connection_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 150 -j 150 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "05_tcp_connection_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 200 -j 200 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "06_tcp_connection_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 250 -j 250 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "07_tcp_connection_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 300 -j 300 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "08_tcp_connection_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 350 -j 350 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "09_tcp_connection_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 400 -j 400 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "10_tcp_connection_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 450 -j 450 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "11_tcp_connection_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h localhost -p 5432 -c 500 -j 500 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "12_unix_socket_1": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 1 -j 1 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "13_unix_socket_50": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 50 -j 50 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "14_unix_socket_100": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 100 -j 100 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "15_unix_socket_150": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 150 -j 150 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "16_unix_socket_200": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 200 -j 200 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "17_unix_socket_250": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 250 -j 250 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "18_unix_socket_300": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 300 -j 300 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "19_unix_socket_350": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 350 -j 350 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "20_unix_socket_400": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 400 -j 400 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "21_unix_socket_450": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 450 -j 450 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    },
    "22_unix_socket_500": {
      "pre_configs": ["shared_preload_libraries = 'pg_wait_sampling'"],
      "workload_pgbench": "pgbench -h /var/run/postgresql -c 500 -j 500 -T 180 -P 10 -r -M prepared -S postgres"
    }
  }
}

For any additional modifications or further details, please let me know!

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Visualize previous experiment

Here is the visualization of the throughput (transactions per second) for TCP/IP and Unix socket connections based on the previous experiment:

Analysis

1. Single Client/Job Performance:
   • TCP/IP: 15953.12 TPS
   • Unix Socket: 27070.79 TPS
2. Scalability:
3. Both TCP/IP and Unix socket connections show high throughput as the number of clients increases.
4. Unix socket connections consistently provide higher TPS, especially with mid-range to high client counts.

Important Note

Further robust evaluations, including multiple runs under various conditions, are recommended. Always test in a non-production environment before making changes to your production setup.

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Once the current one is done, print results and visualize too. I'll go make breakfast for my family meanwhile.

Got it. Once the current experiment completes, I'll print the results and provide a visualization chart. Enjoy your breakfast with your family!

Model used: oai/gpt-4o

Experiment Results

The experiment comparing TCP/IP and Unix socket connections with prepared statements enabled has completed successfully. Below are the results.

Experiment URL:

Pipeline 1350946053

Results Summary

TCP/IP Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 25398.597235
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 992142.107609
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 1588545.295512
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 1750044.197611
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 1757996.967533
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 2248613.682790
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 2359946.098558
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 2703640.532779
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 2797376.511384
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 2815325.432423
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 2830903.089752

Unix Socket Connection:

1. -c 1 / -j 1: Job
2. TPS: 32100.960587
3. -c 50 / -j 50: Job
4. TPS: 1540908.067419
5. -c 100 / -j 100: Job
6. TPS: 2182651.357705
7. -c 150 / -j 150: Job
8. TPS: 2592434.010963
9. -c 200 / -j 200: Job
10. TPS: 2852954.382647
11. -c 250 / -j 250: Job
12. TPS: 3149829.965848
13. -c 300 / -j 300: Job
14. TPS: 3428846.999990
15. -c 350 / -j 350: Job
16. TPS: 3725261.650230
17. -c 400 / -j 400: Job
18. TPS: 3745656.118773
19. -c 450 / -j 450: Job
    • TPS: 3757173.324820
20. -c 500 / -j 500: Job
    • TPS: 3745344.839250

Visualization

I'll now create a visualization of these results.

Here is the visualization of the throughput (transactions per second) for TCP/IP and Unix socket connections with prepared statements:

Analysis

1. Single Client/Job Performance:

   • TCP/IP: 25398.597235 TPS
   • Unix Socket: 32100.960587 TPS

2. Scalability:

3. Both TCP/IP and Unix socket connections show increasing throughput as the number of clients rises.
4. Unix socket connections consistently provide higher TPS across all client numbers, particularly with higher client counts.

Summary

The use of Unix socket connections with prepared statements results in higher throughput compared to TCP/IP connections, especially as the client count increases.

If further comparisons or modifications are needed, feel free to let me know!

Model used: oai/gpt-4o